Intellectual Property and Copyright Reform (63)

1 Name: Citizen 2005-11-01 17:42 ID:OJWN7Axx

ITT, we discuss IP and freedom. DMCA, DRM, GNU, FSF, Microsoft, RIAA, MPAA etc.

In todays technocentric society, the sharing of information has never been easier. We are reaching a critical time, though, as big corporations try to limit our freedoms.

I have my own opinions, but what do you, the people of the world think? Can we have true freedom? How much freedom should we have?

14 Name: Citizen 2005-11-06 12:45 ID:Heaven

>Tell me, if I can just duplicate anything for free, how is anybody who produces IP (software, books, music, movies, etc) supposed to be paid?

By the people who enjoy the authors work.

Are you remotely tech savvy? Do you have a better internet connection than a 56K modem? So why didn't you stop buying software/music cds/DVDs etc, when you can get it all for free?
But maybe your afraid of a total collapse of the industry, like it happend back then when the music cassette was introduced. Or the video recorder. Or the TV. Or the LP. Or radio. All of which allowed easy duplication or free consumption of creative works. We wouldn't want to repeat the disaster that followed them, would we?

A book frees authors from having to sit down personally to tell stories to listeners. A record frees musicians from having to perform before an audience. A copy of software frees programmers from having to enter the numbers themself.
Treating these as intellectual property is wanting to eat your cake and still have it.

15 Name: Citizen 2005-11-06 13:05 ID:Heaven

> Tell me, if I can just duplicate anything for free, how is anybody who produces IP (software, books, music, movies, etc) supposed to be paid? How is a capitalist system supposed to work then?

It's not "supposed" to work then, and it's not supposed to work now. It does work now, it might not then. This is merely a statement of fact, not any kind of value judgement.

This thread has been closed. You cannot post in this thread any longer.