Is the first amendment a falsehood? (49)

26 Name: 19 2006-02-11 19:17 ID:BfdJMPu4

First, >>21 is not me.

>If a slave does not dare to speak out against his master out of fear that he'll be withheld food, would you really call this a problem with freedom of speech?

If I was a person equal in status to the slave owner, would I be wrong to say to him "I think you should let your slave speak", just because I didn't say "I think you should set all your slaves free"? I would be more likely to succeed with the first suggestion rather than the second, don't you think?

> what kind of negative consequences (if any at all) would you be willing to accept for speaking out?

I fail to see how the question is relevant. I felt really strongly about something, maybe I would be prepared to die painfully for speaking out about it. Maybe I am a coward who wouldn't ever voice the slightest disagreement with my boss on any topic. What do my individual reactions have to do with the larger issue of freedom of speech?

> And let's not kid ourselves here, nobody in a first world nation is dependent on a specific job.

Oh really? Did you go around and ask everybody? Or are you just extrapolating from the fact that you and your friends aren't?

This thread has been closed. You cannot post in this thread any longer.