Pssht. If she doesn't love Jesus she isn't worth your time and will give you a disease.
I want a girl who loves God more than me. Because she will be uncompromising in her morals.
I want a girl who is uncompromising. Even in the face of Armageddon. I have a shirt...I got it a while back, it's a Heckler and Koch shirt. It says "In a world of Compromise, some men don't". I want a girl that's like that. Uncompromising. Like an HK era Benelli or an HK93 or something.
See...you're the square. You want a cumdumpster or you want arm candy. I prefer the company of girls who already know what they think.