Anarchists want liberty
Socialists want their own idea of liberty
Islamists want liberty from aggressive American interests.
National socialists wanted the liberty of a standing army, self-determination, not being terrorized by communist militias, taking back what they felt was theirs.

> a logical definition and cannot be misunderstood.

In a dictionary, but not in public consciousness.

> only instances where people have agreed that a crime was done in the name of liberty has been when a gun is pointing at their heads

The one holding the gun would disagree.

Left:
Women should have the liberty to choose what to do with their bodies.
Right:
A baby should have the liberty to a chance at life.

Left:
I should have the liberty to freedom of/from religion.
Right:
I should have the liberty to proselytize to people like my religion requires.

Left:
Those people should have the liberty to not be murdered.
Right:
We should have the liberty to not be murdered by those people.

Meaningless.