Thanks for your input.
>A is A, the rest follows from that.
The law of identity is not a given. Certainly in what most non-theists consider a random universe, A could be B tommorow.
>Logic is universal because existence is universal.
These naturally do not necessarily follow, even so, universal knowledge is reserved for the Omniscient, and those to whom He has revealed knowledge.
>It's arbitrary nonsense. If anyone wishes to seriously put forward a case for this possibility... that would be interesting.
Well, having read this thread, you would have seen at least one person posit that the laws of logic are NOT universal. (the rest have mostly been silent on the matter).