>How can you say that?
I have given my definition of choice several times already. Here it is again:
This is choice:
-I have beliefs and desires
-I consciously assess various ideas for what action to take, according to my goals, beliefs and desires
-I come to a conclusion, the decision is now made
No free will necessary.
>Free will is defined as, and I'll quote from the dictionary here
Don't bother. I'm not interested in free will. I am interested in choice. My dictionaries have not been useful there... defining it as 'selection', and then defining selection as the act of 'choice'.
>What was the purpose behind your question about the apple anyway?
To make sure you agree that entities interact with each other causally.